儿童工作记忆训练效果之争与未来方向&#x0002A;

孙玖陌; 陆逸伦; 王广海; 郝秀荣; 张听雨; 刘洁琼; 蔡丹; 江帆

doi:10.16719/j.cnki.1671-6981.20250210

PDF(655 KB)

心理科学 ›› 2025, Vol. 48 ›› Issue (2) : 371-381. DOI: 10.16719/j.cnki.1671-6981.20250210

发展与教育

儿童工作记忆训练效果之争与未来方向^*

孙玖陌^1,2, 陆逸伦^1,2, 王广海^**2,3, 郝秀荣^1,2, 张听雨^2,3, 刘洁琼^2,3, 蔡丹⁴, 江帆^**2,3

作者信息 +

The Effectiveness of Working Memory Training for Children: Debate and Future Directions

Sun Jiumo^1,2, Lu Yilun^1,2, Wang Guanghai^2,3, Hao Xiurong^1,2, Zhang Tingyu^2,3, Liu Jieqiong^2,3, Cai Dan⁴, Jiang Fan^1,2,3

Author information +

文章历史 +

摘要

工作记忆是对信息进行暂时加工和贮存、容量有限的记忆系统,对儿童的复杂认知和行为表现有重要的决定作用。近年来,儿童工作记忆训练的研究和实践逐渐增多,但工作记忆能否通过训练得以提升,进而改善儿童其他能力还存在巨大争议。系统综述有关研究发现,在典型发育儿童中工作记忆训练产生了近迁移效应,但远迁移效应微弱且结果不一,且效应大小受任务相似性调节。在注意缺陷多动障碍为主的神经发育障碍儿童中,工作记忆训练产生了近迁移效应和特定认知能力上的远迁移效应,但对症状改善的效果有限且不稳定。研究设计与个体差异可能是工作记忆训练效果的重要调节因素。研究为儿童工作记忆训练的未来研究和应用指明了重点人群及努力方向。

Abstract

Working memory (WM) is a limited-capacity memory system responsible for temporarily holding and processing of information. It is a crucial determinant of children's performance in higher order cognitive functions. While working memory develops naturally as children grow older, researchers and clinicians are increasingly interested in whether working memory can be enhanced through training, thereby improving intelligence and daily functioning. The effects of training can be categorized into near transfer and far transfer. With the growing number of relevant studies, the transferability of working memory training in children—particularly far transfer—has become a topic of controversy.
In this study, we reviewed the effects of working memory training in typically developing children and those with neurodevelopmental disorders by synthesizing findings from existing studies. In typically developing children, working memory training was found to produce small to moderate near transfer effects. Evidence for far transfer remains minimal. Although some randomized controlled trials suggest that such training may have positive effects on intelligence and academic performance, meta-analyses indicate that these effects are primarily short-term and limited, largely confined to tasks directly related to the training. However, recent studies suggest that if relevant influencing factors are reasonably controlled or if stratified training is conducted based on the characteristics of typically developing children, such as their initial working memory levels, the potential for improving far transfer effects warrants further exploration. Transfer is influenced by the relationship between the training task and the target task; when the two differ significantly, transfer becomes difficult to observe. Moreover, individual differences such as motivation, initial working memory, and other ability levels cannot be ignored when considering their impact on far transfer effects. For children with neurodevelopmental disorders, particularly attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD), small to moderate improvements in specific near and far transfer effects have been observed in both the short and long term. However, reductions in ADHD symptoms remain unstable. Approximately 1 in 5 children with ADHD exhibit cognitive deficits, suggesting that only a small proportion of ADHD children may benefit from cognitive training, including working memory training. Furthermore, impairments in the central executive system are more pronounced in children with ADHD. Yet, most current training programs primarily target the storage systems of working memory and lack sufficient focus on training the central executive system.
The results of the review indicate that working memory training has a limited effect on far transfer, prompting researchers to explore potential moderators of these results and to investigate measures to enhance the effectiveness of training. Both research design and individual differences significantly influence training outcomes. Key design factors, including task structure similarity, follow-up duration, training amount and frequency, and the engaging nature of the training, impact the results. Additionally, individual differences in children—such as age, baseline ability levels, motivation, and sleep—also affect the training effect. Evaluating the effectiveness of working memory training without considering these moderators is not rigorous. Strategies such as improving participant motivation, optimizing study protocols, and controlling for external factors have been proposed.
This study further integrates and synthesizes the diverse conclusions in the field of children's working memory training. It clarifies which findings have been consistently validated across multiple studies and highlights key populations and directions for future research and practical practice. The study explains the reasons for the small far transfer effects observed in typically developing children and the limited symptom improvement in children with ADHD. It also identifies methodological issues in the current research and offers suggestions for improvement in future studies. Future research should focus on examining the mediating and moderating factors influencing training effects, incorporating tasks targeting the central executive system, strengthening research on combined interventions, and prioritizing targeted approaches to precisely identify and classify children who are most likely to benefit from training.

导出引用

孙玖陌, 陆逸伦, 王广海, 郝秀荣, 张听雨, 刘洁琼, 蔡丹, 江帆. 儿童工作记忆训练效果之争与未来方向^*[J]. 心理科学. 2025, 48(2): 371-381 https://doi.org/10.16719/j.cnki.1671-6981.20250210

Sun Jiumo, Lu Yilun, Wang Guanghai, Hao Xiurong, Zhang Tingyu, Liu Jieqiong, Cai Dan, Jiang Fan. The Effectiveness of Working Memory Training for Children: Debate and Future Directions[J]. Journal of Psychological Science. 2025, 48(2): 371-381 https://doi.org/10.16719/j.cnki.1671-6981.20250210

参考文献

[1] 董素贞, 江帆. (2024). 从儿科临床视角看脑科学研究的重大意义. 中华儿科杂志, 62(5), 393-395.
[2] 黎翠红, 何旭, 郭春彦. (2014). 工作记忆训练的研究述评. 心理与行为研究, 12(3), 407-412.
[3] 刘春雷, 周仁来. (2012). 工作记忆训练对认知功能和大脑神经系统的影响. 心理科学进展, 20(7), 1003-1011.
[4] 吕利丹, 梅自颖, 唐语新, 阎芳. (2023). 中国儿童人口发展新特点与新趋势——基于对第七次全国人口普查数据的分析. 青年研究, 5, 1-16, 94.
[5] 覃丽君. (2019). 工作记忆训练远迁移效应的证据与争议. 心理学进展, 9(1), 64-73.
[6] 余雪. (2020). 工作记忆训练对ADHD干预效果及展望. 中国临床心理学杂志, 28(5), 1072-1076.
[7] 赵鑫, 杨婷, 王天翼, 孙洁. (2022). 任务结构相似性对工作记忆训练迁移效应的影响. 心理科学, 45(6), 1337-1343.
[8] 朱祖德, 段懿行, 王穗苹. (2017). 个体差异对工作记忆训练迁移效果的调节. 心理学报, 49(8), 1022-1030.
[9] Appelgren A., Bengtsson S. L., & Söderqvist S. (2016). Incremental view on intelligence and high intrinsic motivation increase working memory training compliance. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 30(2), 289-293.
[10] Barnett, S. M., & Ceci, S. J. (2002). When and where do we apply what we learn? A taxonomy for far transfer. Psychological Bulletin, 128(4), 612-637.
[11] Berger E. M., Fehr E., Hermes H., Schunk D., & Winkel K. (2020). The impact of working memory training on children's cognitive and noncognitive skills. SSRN Electronic Journal.
[12] Bharadwaj S. V., Yeatts P., & Headley J. (2022). Efficacy of cogmed working memory training program in improving working memory in school-age children with and without neurological insults or disorders: A meta-analysis. Applied Neuropsychology: Child, 11(4), 891-903.
[13] Bigorra A., Garolera M., Guijarro S., & Hervás A. (2016). Long-term far-transfer effects of working memory training in children with ADHD: A randomized controlled trial. European Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 25(8), 853-867.
[14] Camos, V., & Barrouillet, P. (2011). Developmental change in working memory strategies: From passive maintenance to active refreshing. Developmental Psychology, 47(3), 898-904.
[15] Chaldogeridis, A., & Tsiatsos, T. (2022). Gamification techniques and best practices in computerized working memory training: A systematic literature review. Applied Sciences, 12(19), Article 9785.
[16] Chan S., Mueller U., & Masson, M. E. J. (2019). Far-transfer effects of strategy-based working memory training. Frontiers in Psychology, 10, Article 1285.
[17] Chen S. X., Yu J. L., Zhang Q., Zhang J., Zhang Y., & Wang J. H. (2022). Which factor is more relevant to the effectiveness of the cognitive intervention? A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials of cognitive training on symptoms and executive function behaviors of children with attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. Frontiers in Psychology, 12, Article 810298.
[18] Conesa, P. J., & Duñabeitia, J. A. (2021). Effects of computer-based training on children's executive functions and academic achievement. The Journal of Educational Research, 114(6), 562-571.
[19] Cubillo A., Hermes H., Berger E., Winkel K., Schunk D., Fehr E., & Hare T. A. (2023). Intra-individual variability in task performance after cognitive training is associated with long-term outcomes in children. Developmental Science, 26(1), Article e13252.
[20] de Oliveira Rosa V., Rosa Franco A., Abrahão Salum Júnior G., Moreira-Maia C. R., Wagner F., Simioni A., & Paim Rohde, L. A. (2020). Effects of computerized cognitive training as add-on treatment to stimulants in ADHD: A pilot fMRI study. Brain Imaging and Behavior, 14(5), 1933-1944.
[21] Edwards E. J., Zec D., Campbell M., Hoorelbeke K., Koster E. H. W., Derakshan N., & Wynne J. (2022). Cognitive control training for children with anxiety and depression: A systematic review. Journal of Affective Disorders, 300, 158-171.
[22] Ganesan K., Thompson A., Smid C. R., Cañigueral R., Li Y. J., Revill G., .. Steinbeis N. (2024). Cognitive control training with domain-general response inhibition does not change children's brains or behavior. Nature Neuroscience, 27(7), 1364-1375.
[23] Gathercole S. E., Durling E., Evans M., Jeffcock S., & Stone S. (2008). Working memory abilities and children's performance in laboratory analogues of classroom activities. Applied Cognitive Psychology, 22(8), 1019-1037.
[24] Gathercole S. E., Pickering S. J., Ambridge B., & Wearing H. (2004). The structure of working memory from 4 to 15 years of age. Developmental Psychology, 40(2), 177-190.
[25] Gibson B. S., Gondoli D. M., Kronenberger W. G., Johnson A. C., Steeger C. M., & Morrissey R. A. (2013). Exploration of an adaptive training regimen that can target the secondary memory component of working memory capacity. Memory and Cognition, 41(5), 726-737.
[26] Girardeau, G., & Lopes-Dos-Santos, V. (2021). Brain neural patterns and the memory function of sleep. Science, 374(6567), 560-564.
[27] Hajiheidari F., Estaki M., Ashayeri H., & Shahriari Ahmadi M. (2022). The effect of serious games on response inhibition, selective attention and visual-spatial processing in attention deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD): Brain-train and cogniplus games CogniPlus. The Scientific Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine, 11(2), 194-209.
[28] Hamilton M., Ross A., Blaser E., & Kaldy Z. (2022). Proactive interference and the development of working memory. WIREs Reviews: Cognitive Science, 13(3), Article e1593.
[29] Hennessy A., Nichols E. S., Al-Saoud S., Brossard-Racine M., & Duerden E. G. (2024). Identifying cognitive profiles in children with neurodevelopmental disorders using online cognitive testing. Clinical Child Psychology and Psychiatry, 29(2), 591-607.
[30] Holmes, J., & Gathercole, S. E. (2014). Taking working memory training from the laboratory into schools. Educational Psychology, 34(4), 440-450.
[31] Hong Y., Zhang T., Pang C., Zou L., Li M., & Zhou R. L. (2025). The near and far transfer effects of computerized working memory training in typically developing preschool children: Evidence from event-related potentials. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 249, Article 106096.
[32] Izhak, S., & Lavidor, M. (2023). Strategy and core cognitive training effects on working memory performance: A systematic review and meta-analysis. Journal of Cognition and Development, 24(4), 486-513.
[33] Jaeggi S. M., Buschkuehl M., Jonides J., & Shah P. (2011). Short- and long-term benefits of cognitive training. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America, 108(25), 10081-10086.
[34] Jones J. S., Adlam A. L. R., Benattayallah A., & Milton F. N. (2022). The neural correlates of working memory training in typically developing children. Child Development, 93(3), 815-830.
[35] Judd, N., & Klingberg, T. (2021). Training spatial cognition enhances mathematical learning in a randomized study of 17, 000 children. Nature Human Behaviour, 5(11), 1548-1554.
[36] Kane M. J., Hambrick D. Z., Tuholski S. W., Wilhelm O., Payne T. W., & Engle R. W. (2004). The generality of working memory capacity: A latent-variable approach to verbal and visuospatial memory span and reasoning. Journal of Experimental Psychology: General, 133(2), 189-217.
[37] Klingberg, T. (2010). Training and plasticity of working memory. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 14(7), 317-324.
[38] Kofler M. J., Groves N. B., Chan E. S. M., Marsh C. L., Cole A. M., Gaye F., & Singh L. J. (2024). Working memory and inhibitory control deficits in children with ADHD: An experimental evaluation of competing model predictions. Frontiers in Psychiatry, 15, Article 1277583.
[39] Kofler M. J., Rapport M. D., Bolden J., Sarver D. E., & Raiker J. S. (2010). ADHD and working memory: The impact of central executive deficits and exceeding storage/rehearsal capacity on observed inattentive behavior. Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology, 38(2), 149-161.
[40] Long F. F., Zhou W. Y., Zhang T., Zhang Z. Y., & Zhou R. L. (2024). Effects of working memory training on different goals of cognitive reappraisal. Emotion, 24(1), 150-163.
[41] Márquez-Caraveo M. E., Rodríguez-Valentín R., Pérez-Barrón V., Vázquez-Salas R. A., Sánchez-Ferrer J. C., De Castro F., & Lazcano-Ponce E. (2021). Children and adolescents with neurodevelopmental disorders show cognitive heterogeneity and require a person-centered approach. Scientific Reports, 11(1), Article 18463.
[42] Martínez-Briones B. J., Fernández-Harmony T., Garófalo Gómez N., Biscay-Lirio R. J., & Bosch-Bayard J. (2020). Working memory in children with learning disorders: An EEG power spectrum analysis. Brain Sciences, 10(11), Article 817.
[43] Martinussen R., Hayden J., Hogg-Johnson S., & Tannock R. (2005). A meta-analysis of working memory impairments in children with attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 44(4), 377-384.
[44] Melby-Lervåg M., Redick T. S., & Hulme C. (2016). Working memory training does not improve performance on measures of intelligence or other measures of “far transfer”: Evidence from a meta-analytic review. Perspectives on Psychological Science, 11(4), 512-534.
[45] Morrison, A. B., & Chein, J. M. (2011). Does working memory training work? The promise and challenges of enhancing cognition by training working memory. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review, 18(1), 46-60.
[46] Nejati V., Derakhshan Z., & Mohtasham A. (2023). The effect of comprehensive working memory training on executive functions and behavioral symptoms in children with attention deficit-hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). Asian Journal of Psychiatry, 81, Article 103469.
[47] Pahor A., Seitz A. R., & Jaeggi S. M. (2022). Near transfer to an unrelated N-back task mediates the effect of N-back working memory training on matrix reasoning. Nature Human Behaviour, 6(9), 1243-1256.
[48] Pascoe L., Spencer-Smith M., Wiley J., Lee K., Roberts G., Josev E., & Anderson P. (2019). Child motivation and family environment influence outcomes of working memory training in extremely preterm children. Journal of Cognitive Enhancement, 3(4), 396-404.
[49] Peijnenborgh J. C. A. W., Hurks P. M., Aldenkamp A. P., Vles J. S. H., & Hendriksen, J. G. M. (2016). Efficacy of working memory training in children and adolescents with learning disabilities: A review study and meta-analysis. Neuropsychological Rehabilitation, 26(5-6), 645-672.
[50] Peng J., Mo L., Huang P., & Zhou Y. (2017). The effects of working memory training on improving fluid intelligence of children during early childhood. Cognitive Development, 43, 224-234.
[51] Peng, P., & Swanson, H. L. (2022). The domain-specific approach of working memory training. Developmental Review, 65, Article 101035.
[52] Pergher V., Shalchy M. A., Pahor A., Van Hulle M. M., Jaeggi S. M., & Seitz A. R. (2020). Divergent research methods limit understanding of working memory training. Journal of Cognitive Enhancement, 4(1), 100-120.
[53] Pugin F., Metz A. J., Wolf M., Achermann P., Jenni O. G., & Huber R. (2015). Local increase of sleep slow wave activity after three weeks of working memory training in children and adolescents. Sleep, 38(4), 607-614.
[54] Rapport M. D., Orban S. A., Kofler M. J., & Friedman L. M. (2013). Do programs designed to train working memory, other executive functions, and attention benefit children with ADHD? A meta-analytic review of cognitive, academic, and behavioral outcomes. Clinical Psychology Review, 33(8), 1237-1252.
[55] Redick, T. S. (2019). The hype cycle of working memory training. Current Directions in Psychological Science, 28(5), 423-429.
[56] Reynolds M. R., Niileksela C. R., Gignac G. E., & Sevillano C. N. (2022). Working memory capacity development through childhood: A longitudinal analysis. Developmental Psychology, 58(7), 1254-1263.
[57] Roque-Gutierrez, E., & Ibbotson, P. (2023). Working memory training improves children's syntactic ability but not vice versa: A randomized control trial. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 227, Article 105593.
[58] Rowe A., Titterington J., Holmes J., Henry L., & Taggart L. (2019). Interventions targeting working memory in 4-11 year olds within their everyday contexts: A systematic review. Developmental Review, 52, 1-23.
[59] Sala, G., & Gobet, F. (2017). Working memory training in typically developing children: A meta-analysis of the available evidence. Developmental Psychology, 53(4), 671-685.
[60] Sala, G., & Gobet, F. (2019). Cognitive training does not enhance general cognition. Trends in Cognitive Sciences, 23(1), 9-20.
[61] Sala, G., & Gobet, F. (2020). Working memory training in typically developing children: A multilevel meta-analysis. Psychonomic Bulletin and Review, 27(3), 423-434.
[62] Scullin M. K., Trotti L. M., Wilson A. G., Greer S. A., & Bliwise D. L. (2012). Nocturnal sleep enhances working memory training in Parkinson's disease but not Lewy body dementia. Brain, 135(9), 2789-2797.
[63] Simmering, V. R. (2012). The development of visual working memory capacity during early childhood. Journal of Experimental Child Psychology, 111(4), 695-707.
[64] Söderqvist S., Matsson H., Peyrard-Janvid M., Kere J., & Klingberg T. (2014). Polymorphisms in the dopamine receptor 2 gene region influence improvements during working memory training in children and adolescents. Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience, 26(1), 54-62.
[65] Sonuga-Barke E., Bitsakou P., & Thompson M. (2010). Beyond the dual pathway model: Evidence for the dissociation of timing, inhibitory, and delay-related impairments in attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder. Journal of the American Academy of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry, 49(4), 345-355.
[66] Studer-Luethi B., Bauer C., & Perrig W. J. (2016). Working memory training in children: Effectiveness depends on temperament. Memory and Cognition, 44(2), 171-186.
[67] Swanson, H. L. (2017). Verbal and visual-spatial working memory: What develops over a life span? Developmental Psychology, 53(5), 971-995.
[68] Thorndike, E. L., & Woodworth, R. S. (1901). The influence of improvement in one mental function upon the efficiency of other functions: III. Functions involving attention, observation and discrimination. Psychological Review, 8(6), 553-564.
[69] Tullo D.,& Jaeggi, S. M. (2022). Working memory training: Meta-analyses and clinical implications In J W Schwieter, & Z S Wen (Eds), The cambridge handbook of working memory and language (pp 881-906) Cambridge University Press Meta-analyses and clinical implications. In J. W. Schwieter, & Z. S. Wen (Eds.), The cambridge handbook of working memory and language (pp. 881-906). Cambridge University Press.
[70] van der Donk M., Hiemstra-Beernink A. C., Tjeenk-Kalff A., van der Leij A., & Lindauer R. (2015). Cognitive training for children with ADHD: A randomized controlled trial of cogmed working memory training and 'paying attention in class'. Frontiers in Psychology, 6, Article 1081.
[71] van der Donk, M. L. A., Hiemstra-Beernink A. C., Tjeenk-Kalff A. C., van der Leij A., & Lindauer, R. J. L. (2020). Predictors and moderators of treatment outcome in cognitive training for children with ADHD. Journal of Attention Disorders, 24(13), 1914-1927.
[72] Vernucci S., Canet Juric L., Introzzi I., & Richard's M. M. (2020). Working memory training in children: A review of basic methodological criteria. Psychological Reports, 123(3), 605-632.
[73] Vernucci S., Canet-Juric L., & Richard's, M. M. (2023). Effects of working memory training on cognitive and academic abilities in typically developing school-age children. Psychological Research, 87(1), 308-326.
[74] Vladisauskas M., Belloli L. M. L., Fernández Slezak D., & Goldin A. P. (2022). A machine learning approach to personalize computerized cognitive training interventions. Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence, 5, Article 788605.
[75] Wang L., Sheng A., Chang L., & Zhou R. L. (2022). Improving fluid intelligence of children through working memory training: The role of inhibition control. Frontiers in Psychology, 13, Article 1025036.
[76] Wang Z. W., Zhou R. L., & Shah P. (2014). Spaced cognitive training promotes training transfer. Frontiers in Human Neuroscience, 8, Article 217.
[77] Watrin L., Hülür G., & Wilhelm O. (2022). Training working memory for two years-no evidence of transfer to intelligence. Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 48(5), 717-733.
[78] Westwood S. J., Parlatini V., Rubia K., Cortese S., Sonuga-Barke E. J. S., & European ADHD Guidelines Group (EAGG). (2023). Computerized cognitive training in attention-deficit/hyperactivity disorder (ADHD): A meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials with blinded and objective outcomes. Molecular Psychiatry, 28(4), 1402-1414.
[79] Wibral M., Pampu N., Priesemann V., Siebenhühner F., Seiwert H., Lindner M., .. Vicente R. (2013). Measuring information-transfer delays. PLoS ONE, 8(2), Article e55809.
[80] Xu J., Deng M. Q., Nan W. Y., & Cai D. (2021). The effects of working memory training in children revealed by behavioral responses and ERP. Brain and Behavior, 11(8), Article e2310.
[81] Zhang Q., Wang C. P., Zhao Q. W., Yang L., Buschkuehl M., & Jaeggi S. M. (2019). The malleability of executive function in early childhood: Effects of schooling and targeted training. Developmental Science, 22(2), Article e12748.
[82] Zhang Y. X., Tolmie A., & Gordon R. (2022). The relationship between working memory and arithmetic in primary school children: A meta-analysis. Brain Sciences, 13(1), Article 22.
[83] Zhou J. T., Li J. F. Z., Zhao Q., Ou P. X., & Zhao W. (2022). Working memory deficits in children with schizophrenia and its mechanism, susceptibility genes, and improvement: A literature review. Frontiers in Psychiatry, 13, Article 899344.
[84] Zinke K., Noack H., & Born J. (2018). Sleep augments training-induced improvement in working memory in children and adults. Neurobiology of Learning and Memory, 147, 46-53.

基金

*本研究得到国家自然科学基金委员会（U23A20170,82071493,32471113）、上海市高水平地方高校建设创新团队：脑认知原理解析（SHSMU-ZDCX20211900）、上海交通大学医学院高水平创新团队：社交障碍的神经机制及其干预策略（SHSMU-ZDCX20211100）、上海市卫生健康委2020年“生命早期健康与疾病”协同创新集群项目（2020CXJQ01）和上海市浦江人才计划（22PJC074）的资助