Psychological Science ›› 2012, Vol. 35 ›› Issue (3): 581-587.

Previous Articles     Next Articles

The Ease-of-task and Part-List Cuing Effect

  

  • Received:2010-04-26 Revised:2011-09-08 Online:2012-05-20 Published:2012-05-20
  • Contact: Xiping Liu

任务难度与部分线索效应

唐卫海1,谢思源2,刘湍丽3,刘希平4   

  1. 1. 天津市西青区宾水西道393号 天津师范大学教育学院心理系
    2.
    3. 天津师范大学
    4. 天津师范大学教育学院心理系
  • 通讯作者: 刘希平
  • 基金资助:
    教育部人文社科规划项目

Abstract: The part-list cuing effect is that a presentation of a subset of learnt items as retrieval cues can have detrimental effects on recall of the remaining items. There were 3 experiments in the current study to investigate the part-list cuing effect with Chinese words. We used the un-related/related words semantically and different orders of words presentation when people studied the lists to control the difficulty of the three tasks, in order to know if the task difficulty would be a factor to affect the effect of part-list cuing. All of them used the same design model which included study-test circle. All the participants learned a same words list of 30 items in study phase for per experiment, and then the participants of control group were instructed to free recall all the items in un-cued condition, the cued group were provided with a subset of 10 intralist items and use them as retrieval cues for recalling the remaining items. The different performance between cued group and un-cued group on reminding items showed the size of the effect. Experiment 1 used 30 words out of 6 categories but presented randomly when people studied. What the participants studied in experiment 2 were 30 words un-related semantically while presented randomly. In experiment 3 other 30 words were used out of those 6 categories as well while presented in the way of categories. The findings show that:(1)part-list cuing effect exists all the time whatever the task difficulty is. That means the Retrieval Inhibition Hypothesis is right. (2) It is the average difficulty task under which people got the biggest size of part-list cuing effect. The sizes of part-list cuing effects under easiest task and hardest task conditions are both decreasing. That means we cannot get the conclusion that the Strategy Disruption Hypothesis must be wrong.

Key words: part-list cuing effect, Strategy Disruption Hypothesis , difficulty-of-task, size of pat-list cuing effect

摘要: 部分线索效应是指在学习一个词表后,呈现已学项目中的一部分作为回忆线索去回忆其他项目时,回忆效果反而不如没有线索组的效果好。研究通过三个实验探讨了不同任务难度的部分线索效应。结果表明:(1)在中文词表记忆中存在部分线索效应;(2)随着学习材料难度的提高由部分线索造成的提取成绩的削减量降低。这一研究结果支持了部分线索效应的策略破坏假说。

关键词: 部分线索效应, 策略破坏假说, 任务难度, 部分线索削弱量