A Meta-Analysis of Mental Health of Pilots during the Past Decade
Deng Lifang
(Institute of Psychology and behavior,Beihang University, Beijing 100191)
Abstract
Although the mental health status of the Chinese Pilots has been highlighted by many researchers, the results of these researches are contradictory. There are different control standards about the mental health status of Pilots and different control standards may come to different conclusions, resulting in lack of comparability among different research. What’s more, as the years goes by and with the development of society, the mental health status of Pilots of the different periods are different. Thus, their mental health status remains unclear. So this article aims to investigate the mental health status of the Chinese Pilots during the past decade, which includes two aspects. One is that, as time going on, what happened to the mental health state of Chinese Pilots? The other is that compared with the general adult norm, what about psychological health state of Chinese pilots and are there any differences in it among different types of pilots?
In this study, 20 literatures pertaining to the mental health status of the Chinese Pilots were used, and 5070 Pilots in China were surveyed. All the literatures researching the mental health of pilots during the 2001 to 2010 had used the Symptom Checklist 90 (SCL-90) as a judgment test tool. We analyzed the literatures by the way of Meta-analysis and cross-temporal meta-analysis.
The results showed that (1) The SCL-90 scores of the Chinese pilots increased in 2000-2001. During 2001 to 2009, The SCL-90 date showed a U-shaped curve, the lowest scores in 2005 and reached a peak in 2009. The scores of the factors anxiety, interpersonal, sensitivity, depression and fear have changed remarkably during the 10 years. (2) The mean effect size of all the factors in The SCL-90 concentrated between-0.27-0.46. Further, the factors of somatization, depression, anxiety and horrorare had no significant different with the general adult norm and the other five factors had significant different with the general adult norm and the scores of the other five factors are obviously lower than the norm. (3) The correlation analysis results between different pilot types (Civil aviation and military pilots) and the factors of the SCL-90 showed that the Civil aviation pilots’ mental health level is lower than the military pilots, but the difference did not reach significant level (0.069<0.288,P>0.05)。
Therefore, to enhance the pilots’ mental health education, to improve the ability of adaption and international cooperation is imminent. In addition, the management should give pilots the appropriate decompression as soon as possible and based on the findings to establish the relevant supporting measures to ensure flight safety and improve their treatment.
Key words Pilot, SCL-90, Meta-analysis, cross-temporal meta-analysis
Key words
[Keywords] Pilot, SCL-90, Meta-analysis, cross-temporal meta-analysis
{{custom_sec.title}}
{{custom_sec.title}}
{{custom_sec.content}}
References
参考文献
*白菁, 李娜, 陆铮, 费华煊, 陈晶晶, 余烟兰.(2010). 人文疗养护理对飞行员心理和社会功能的影响.解放军护理杂志,27(5):656-659
崔红,王登峰,万梅,李雪冰,李原,张恒.(2004). 军事飞行员症状自评量表评定及其元分
析.中国临床康复,8(27):5937-5939
*董燕,施承孙,周晓梅,侯桂芝.(2005).飞行人员心理健康状况和个性特征分析.中国行为医学科学, 14(8):757-758
*傅瑜弘.(2006). 初教级飞行学员的心理健康状况研究.硕士学位论文,吉林大学:1-91
*侯方高,王强,张越.(2002). 海军飞行人员心理健康调查. 海军医学志, 23(2): 168
*李学彦,杨晓凤,邵丽春,贾建平.(2001) 功能性消化不良飞行员的心理卫生状况研究.中国心理卫生杂志,15(6):423
*刘军,宋华淼,敖景文,陈强,张春芳.(2001). 空军地勤及后勤人员心理健康调查分析,第四军医
大学,吉林军医学院学报, 23(2):87-90
*李静,凌莉,梁朝辉,杨仕云,肖毅.(2004). 民航飞行员心理健康状况的调查分析. 热带医
学杂志, 4(4):421-424
*刘新玲,王耀平,王趱.(2004). 199 名飞行员心理健康状况调查分析.中国疗养医学 13(3):166-167
*李惠荣,杜丕海,王米佳.(2007). 用量表评价高性能战斗机飞行人员的心理健康状况.临床军医杂志, 35(2):274-275
*任春海,赵明,王现锋,贾伟东.(2003). 某直升机团飞行人员心理健康症状调查分析.医学动物防制,19(4):228-229
*田静,洪威.(2009). 疗养期间心理干预对飞行员心理健康影响效果研究.中国疗养医学,
18(1):36-37
王煜蕙,王霞,张志林.(2002). 1017例就诊飞行人员的心理干预及疗效分析[J].中华航空航天
医学杂志, 13(1): 5-7
*王东耀 ,刘军,刘成,邢安辉,张玉环,蒋艳.(2006). 维和官兵人格特征和心理健康状况的分析.
第四军医大学学报, 27(20):1910-1912
*吴以武,乔宗林,李悲雁,王晓惠. 军事飞行员心理健康状况调查.(2008). 中国疗养医学,
17(11):696-698
*吴以武,乔宗林.(2008). 团体心理训练对军事飞行人员心理健康的影响.中国疗养医学, 17(12):721-722
辛自强,池丽萍.(2008). 横断历史研究:以元分析考察社会变迁中的心理发展.华东师范大学
学报(教育科学版),26(2):44-51
辛自强,张 梅.(2009). 1992年以来中学生心理健康的变迁:一项横断历史研究.心理学报,
41(11):69-78
*于和青.(2006. )民航飞行员心理状态与个性及应付方式研究. 硕士学位论文, 山东大学.
*张文广, 郑曙峰, 蒋一平, 张建华. (2009).飞行员吸烟情况及吸烟者心理健康状况调查.中国
误诊学杂志, 9(11):2765-2766
*钟佳音.(2009). 飞行人员心理健康状况与影响因素的调查研究. 硕士学位论文, 吉林大学:
394-395
Glass GV, et al. (1981). Meta-analysis in social research. Beverly Hills. CA: Sage Publications, 3-8.
Knight G.P., Fabes, R. A.,&H igg in s,D.A.( 1996).Concernsabout drawing causal inferences from m etaanaly ses: an example in the study of gender differences in aggression. Psychological Bulletin, 119(3),410- 421.