The Effect of Perceived Interpersonal Control on Cooperation Behavior: An ERPs Investigation Using the Prisoner’s Dilemma Game

Kai DOU

Journal of Psychological Science ›› 2015, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (3) : 643-650.

PDF(912 KB)
PDF(912 KB)
Journal of Psychological Science ›› 2015, Vol. 38 ›› Issue (3) : 643-650.

The Effect of Perceived Interpersonal Control on Cooperation Behavior: An ERPs Investigation Using the Prisoner’s Dilemma Game

  • Kai DOU2
Author information +
History +

Abstract

Cooperative behavior refers to a prosocial act that one makes to override his / her optimized interest to maximize the benefit of a group. One is required to sacrifice his / her benefit in order to behave cooperatively, thus leading to the occurrence of social dilemma (i.e., a situation where short-term / personal interest is conflict with long-term / group interest). Perceived interpersonal control (PIC) is defined as a subjective perception of controlling relationship in interpersonal processes. Previous studies have found that PIC is a factor that has influence on one’s cooperative behavior. To be more specific, it is demonstrated that high PIC promotes cooperative behavior, but the underlying neural mechanism receives little research. Hence, this study mainly focuses on the electrophysiological mechanisms of the effect of PIC on cooperative behavior. In line with the limited repetitive prisoner dilemma game, we designed a resource-sharing game task using sale task as script, a very common task in the organizational context, to investigate individuals’ cooperative behavior during social dilemma. Participants’ PIC was manipulated by setting the move order of participants and their counterparts during the experimental task. 18 part-time postgraduate students participated in the study, but 3 participants were eliminated due to enormous artifacts, thus leaving 15 valid participant included in statistical analyses. During stimulus presentation, the EEG was recorded using a amplifier (Brain Product) from a 64 electrodes of the international 10-20 system. First, we employed ANOVA to examine whether the manipulation of PIC was successful. Results indicated that compared to participants in middle and low PIC conditions, participants in high PIC condition perceived less self-control conflict, considered the “not to share” choice less tempting, used less willpower when chose the “to share” option, perceived higher interpersonal control, assumed the opponent was highly influenced by them, and more believed the opponent would follow their choices. These findings suggested that PIC was successfully manipulated. Second, results of behavioral outcomes found that participants with high PIC spent less time making a decision and had higher cooperation rate. These results were consistent with previous ones and suggest that compared to low and middle levels of PIC, participants with high PIC felt less self-control conflict, and believed their decisions would have more impact on the final decision, therefore promoting partners’ cooperation to achieve a “win-win” outcome. Last, the behavioral outcomes were supported by ERPs results. It was found that compared to low PIC condition, the amplitudes of P2 and N2 were lower for people who were performing Prisoner’s game with high PIC. Regression analysis further showed that proportion of cooperation was positively and negatively related N2 and P2, respectively. This suggested that the influence of high PIC on cooperative behavior on ERPs level was reflected in the decrease in the perception of uncertainty and the increase in conflict inhibition. Specifically, source analysis suggested that right prefrontal cortex and middle frontal gyrus were activated more greatly. In the situation of social dilemma, when individuals were faced with temptation (e.g., short-term rewards), the nucleus accumbens, a neural basis responsible for reward, was activated. If prefrontal cortex at this moment succeeded in regulating the activation of nucleus accumbens, then people were more likely to inhibit their impulse, thus promoting their cooperative behavior. The current findings suggested that people high in PIC were more willing to cooperate. More important, such effect was related with the amplitude of P2 and N2. Limitations and contributions were addressed.

Key words

perceived interpersonal control / cooperative behavior / prisoner delimma / event related potential

Cite this article

Download Citations
Kai DOU. The Effect of Perceived Interpersonal Control on Cooperation Behavior: An ERPs Investigation Using the Prisoner’s Dilemma Game[J]. Journal of Psychological Science. 2015, 38(3): 643-650
PDF(912 KB)

Accesses

Citation

Detail

Sections
Recommended

/