Journal of Psychological Science ›› 2023, Vol. 46 ›› Issue (2): 320-328.

Previous Articles     Next Articles

Different Affective Arousal and Adaptation Pattern between Core and Moral Disgust: Evidence from Subjective Emotional Experience and Autonomic Nervous System Activity

Wang Qin, Wang Yuqi, Liu Xinyu, Xu Huifang, Luo Wenyu#br#   

  1. Key Research Base of Humanities and Social Sciences of the Ministry of Education, Academy of Psychology and Behavior, Tianjin Normal University;
    Faculty of Psychology, Tianjin Normal University, Tianjin, 300387
  • Received:2020-12-26 Revised:2022-01-25 Online:2023-03-20 Published:2023-03-20

核心厌恶与道德厌恶唤醒与适应的特异性:来自主观情绪体验和自主神经活动的证据

王 芹  王雨琪 刘欣宇 许慧芳 罗文妤   

  1. 教育部人文社会科学重点研究基地天津师范大学心理与行为研究院,天津师范大学心理学部,天津, 300387
  • 通讯作者: 王芹*

Abstract: Abstract: Disgust has been considered as one of six basic emotions that has the adaptive function to protect us from the harmful substances. Previous studies have shown that disgust is accompanied by increased parasympathetic responses. However, opposite results have been reported. Different types of elicitor may have contributed to existing contradictory findings. A wide range of stimuli can evoke disgust. Core disgust refers to the original form of disgust, triggered by potentially toxic visual, gustatory, or olfactory stimuli that could contaminate the body (i.e., contaminated foods). Moral disgust seems unique to humans, triggered by the violation of moral values or socially inappropriate people and behaviors. It is generally assumed that core disgust serves a disease-avoidance function by facilitating rejection and avoidance of contamination-related stimulus, while moral disgust play an important role in the regulation of social behavior and is crucial for maintenance of social norms. The evolutionary adaptation theory holds that disgust has evolved from the antecedent distaste response and different types of disgust originate from core disgust. Empirical studies on the homogeneity and heterogeneity between core and moral disgust are sparse and inconsistent. There has been increased debate concerning whether disgust reactions elicited by different types of elicitor have the common origin. The major aim of the present study was to explore whether core and moral disgust may dissociate in their affective self-reports and response patterns of the autonomic nervous system, as well as the time-course of emotional responses. Laboratory psycho-physiological experiment was conducted to examine subjective and physiological responses to disgust-evoking pictures. 32 female university students (16 in the core disgust group and 16 in the moral disgust group) were tested individually in a quiet testing room, with each participant session lasting around 40 mins. Disgust pictures were presented to each participant in a random order via Super Lab system on a monitor screen. Automatic physiological responses were collected continuously by Biopac MP150 physiological recording system. The skin conductance, heart rate and heart period variability were recorded and analyzed. Participants were shown 10 pictures at four different time points to explore the emotional arousal and development of two types of disgust. The experiment used a two-factor repeated measures design of 2 (group: core disgust and moral disgust)?2(stage: 0, 2, 4, and 6min), in which the group was the between-subjects design and the stage was the within-subjects design. Within each disgust condition, 10 pictures were presented and each picture lasted for 10s on the screen. Participants were asked to rate the intensity of each emotion (happiness, sadness, anger, disgust, and fear) before and immediately after exposed to disgust pictures on a scale of 1-7(where 1 indicated an absence of that emotion and 7 indicated strong intensity). Repeated Measures ANOVAs were used to analyze the subjective, electrodermal and cardiovascular reactions of core and moral disgust. The results showed that core and moral disgust pictures used in this study generated similar overall levels of subjective disgust reaction. Both types of disgust were concomitant with other negative emotions. Core disgust elicitors generated more fear, whereas sociomoral stimuli evoked more angry and sad. The disgust-induced subjective responses were associated with different patterns of autonomic reactivity. Core disgust increased high frequency component of heart period variability and sociomoral disgust increased heart rate. Moreover, responses to core and sociomoral disgust elicitors varied in different ways over time. Participants experienced decreased disgust when core disgust elicitors repeatedly presented and a decrease in high frequency component of heart period variability was observed. Repeated exposure to sociomoral disgust elicitors increased skin conductance responses, while self-reported disgust response seemed more resistant to change over time. Taken together, these results suggested that core disgust and moral disgust are separate emotions, appears to elicit heterogeneous subjective and autonomic reaction.

Key words: Core disgust, moral disgust, adaptation, subjective emotional experience, autonomic nervous activity

摘要: 摘要:不同诱发物引发的厌恶情绪是否具有同质性目前存在争论。研究选择核心厌恶和道德厌恶图片为实验材料,以女大学生为被试,考察情绪诱发和适应阶段的主观情绪体验和自主神经活动变化。结果表明,(1)核心厌恶情绪下个体心率变异性显著升高,在情绪主观体验和生理唤醒上出现适应性反应;(2)道德厌恶下个体心率显著上升,没有出现情绪适应性反应。研究结果支持了核心厌恶和道德厌恶情绪的特异性观点。

关键词: 核心厌恶, 道德厌恶, 适应性, 主观情绪体验, 自主神经活动