Psychological Science ›› 2018, Vol. 41 ›› Issue (5): 1110-1116.

Previous Articles     Next Articles

The Influence of Evidence Order and Testimony’s Confidence on 5-Year Children’s Causal Inference

  

  • Received:2017-09-08 Revised:2018-06-20 Online:2018-09-20 Published:2018-09-20

证据顺序和证词自信度对学前末期儿童因果推理的影响

陈水平1,2,刘雁伶1,周蔓3,胡竹菁4   

  1. 1. 江西科技师范大学
    2. 江西师范大学
    3. 江西省人民政府直属机关保育院
    4. 江西师范大学心理学院
  • 通讯作者: 胡竹菁

Abstract: Until recently, the psychological mechanism of the interaction of the three kinds of information(Statistical information, experimental results, and testimonies) in children's scientific thinking has not been elucidated (Sobel & Kushnir, 2013). In this study, research paradigm from Bridgers et al(2016) was used in two experiments to explore the influence of order of two kinds of evidence: adult’s testimony and adult’s experiment, on 5-year-old children’s causal inference. children's perception of the level of testimony’s confidence also was analyzed. Experiment 1 adopted a 2×2 completely randomized experiment design, the independent variable was the informant’s self-confidence (two levels: self-confidence, not-confidence) and the order of evidence (two levels: testimony prior to experiment, experiment prior to testimony), the dependent variable was the frequency of children’s choice of candidate cause. Both testimony and experiment were given by an adult female in a laptop, in respective. 132 preschool children(77 boys and 55 girls, mean age 68.2 months) took part in experiment 1. The results showed that there were more children choice cause according to testimony in condition that experiment prior to testimony, and according to experiment in condition that testimony prior to experiment, resulting in a recency effect. children was not sensitive to the testimony’s confidence and informant’s awareness. Experiment 1 found that children was not sensitive to the testimony’s confidence, which might be unaware of the information of testimony’s confidence. Experiment 2 adopted the same experiment design of experiment 1, but appended a confidence question to the end of testimony. 127 preschool children(70 boys and 57 girls, mean age 69.3 months) took part in experiment 2. The results showed that there were more children in condition of confidence testimony than in condition of not-confidence testimony choice cause according to testimony, but the effect of evidence order were removed. It seemed that 5-year-old children gave the same weight to adult’s testimony and experiment, and the change of evidence order brought a recency effect on children’s causal inference, but recency effect would been eliminate by appending a confidence question to the end of testimony. That children was not sensitive to the self-confidence of testimony might be unaware of it. The follow-up Research should focus on the interaction of independent exploration, observing others experiment and informant testimony on preschool children's scientific thinking, on the influence of evidence strength and on how to improve children's scientific thinking in preschool curriculum.

Key words: evidence order, the confidence of testimony, preschool children, causal inference

摘要: 开展两个实验探究证据顺序和证词自信水平对5岁儿童因果推理的影响机制。132名和127名5岁儿童分别参与实验1和实验2。实验1发现证据顺序对儿童因果推理的影响表现为近因效应,但证词的自信水平差异不影响儿童的因果推理;实验2发现如果儿童注意到证词的自信水平信息,他们更倾向于在自信证词条件依据证词推断因果关系,证据顺序的影响力被削弱。研究结果说明证据顺序变化导致易受影响的近因效应。

关键词: 证据顺序, 证词自信度, 学前儿童, 因果推理