The Loss of Natural Self-Evidence ——On the Blankenburg’s Schizophrenia Theory

Xian-Jun Xu CHEN Wei

Journal of Psychological Science ›› 2017, Vol. 40 ›› Issue (4) : 1011-1016.

PDF(307 KB)
PDF(307 KB)
Journal of Psychological Science ›› 2017, Vol. 40 ›› Issue (4) : 1011-1016.

The Loss of Natural Self-Evidence ——On the Blankenburg’s Schizophrenia Theory

  • Xian-Jun Xu1,CHEN Wei
Author information +
History +

Abstract

The field of schizophrenia research is dominated by the theory which focuses on the delusion. This theory advocates that relative special symptoms of schizophrenia can be observed most easily in the delusion perception. Then nondelusional schizophrenia which doesn’t have obvious symptoms is neglected. In Blankenburg’s view, though schizophrenic patients exhibit their world in the delusion more clearly and intuitively than in other psychopathological appearance, but it doesn’t mean that schizophrenia only manifests itself in the delusion. He tried to search the essence of schizophrenia in the nondelusional and symptom-poor forms, especially hebephrenic and simple type. He belongs to the tradition of phenomenological psychopathology founded by Karl Jaspers, so his methodology is phenomenological. In 1912, Jaspers proposed that phenomenology should be the preparative discipline of psychopathology because it could help psychiatrists understand what the patients really experienced. The phenomenological psychopathology focuses on the study of subjective experiences and gives high value to the self-descriptions of patients. So it differentiates greatly from the biological psychopathology which focuses on the study of neurological mechanisms. In the last decade, phenomenological psychiatry has underwent a rather prominent recovery because much theoretical and empirical work becomes to be interested in the systematic study of subjective experience of mental disorder. Despite progress in identifying the neural substrates of schizophrenia, phenomenology deserves to be at the center of any effort to investigate schizophrenia, because it makes accessible the symptoms reported by the patient and it can help researchers find out etiology of schizophrenia. Based on the phenomenological analysis of his patients’ self-descriptions, Blankenburg put forward that the loss of natural self-evidence is the core of schizophrenic change. According to the Edmund Husserl’s transcendental phenomenology, the loss of natural self-evidence can be traced back to the four changes: (1) the change of the relation to the world; (2) the change of temporal construction; (3) the change of self-construction; (4) the change of the relation to others. First, schizophrenic patients can’t deal with their world like the healthy because they have lost the transcendental planning or passive genesis and they have to be charged with the work which should have been done in the unconsciousness or automatically. So they exhaust their strength shortly and express the schizophrenic asthenia. Second, schizophrenic patients’ time construction happens to be spilt and the integrity of their past, now and future has collapsed. They can’t utilize their past, so they can’t enter their future. Third, schizophrenic patients are short of self-supporting and can’t accomplish self-construction. More specifically, their self-weakness occurs on the low-level of self, i.e. the level of transcendental performance. In other words, the defected is their transcendental self that is the original and primary one. Four, schizophrenic patients’ relation to others or their intersubjective construction has changed greatly and it is the source of the loss of natural self-evidence. DSM-5 calls it asociality. Patients can’t shift themselves into others’ place automatically due to the loss of common sense, so they have to do it consciously and hardly. The psychiatrists in the English countries mainly used to rely on the positive symptoms in the diagnose of schizophrenia, but in the recent decades they become to pay more attention to the negative symptoms. And DSM-5 has ranked the negative symptoms as one of the core characters of schizophrenia. In this case Blankenburg’s work has special importance for the study of schizophrenia because it provides the best explanation of the subject dimension of the negative symptoms. The researchers who want to understand the negative symptoms, mustn’t ignore his work. As one of the greatest representative of the phenomenological psychopathology, he has influenced on the temporary study of schizophrenia and cognitive sciences deeply. Recently, Leonhard Schilbach and others have suggested that the “mirror neuron system” (MNS) and the “mentalizing network” (MENT) are key substrates of the loss of natural self-evidence.

Key words

schizophrenia, phenomenological psychopathology, self-evidence, negative symptom, social cognition

Cite this article

Download Citations
Xian-Jun Xu CHEN Wei. The Loss of Natural Self-Evidence ——On the Blankenburg’s Schizophrenia Theory[J]. Journal of Psychological Science. 2017, 40(4): 1011-1016
PDF(307 KB)

Accesses

Citation

Detail

Sections
Recommended

/